Best Organic Coffee K-Cups For The Discerning Enthusiast

As our tastes and preferences evolve, they can often take our understanding of the best K cup coffee in a new direction. 

lifeboost-coffee-fairtrade-organic-whole-bean-dark-roast-12oz

Try The Healthiest, Tastiest Organic Coffee Ever!


One area where this shines is the user’s shift towards organic products. From being niche, these are now mainstream. You can easily take your pick from the best organic coffee K-cups from several choices. 

A great thing about K cups is that they can easily adjust to meet consumer requirements. So we get to enjoy a great cup of coffee without guesswork and have it made to our preference. Talk about having your cake and eating it too!

Read more: Buy the best organic coffee beans.

Organic coffee has a promise of being sustainably grown coffee. The demand for organic represents an interest not just in the coffee, but also into how and where it is grown.

Top 10 Organic Coffee K Cups For Your Keurig

  1. Caza Trail Coffee Organic Extra Bold Single Serve Cups
  2. Death Wish Coffee Single Serve Capsules for Keurig K-Cup Brewers
  3. SF Bay Coffee Organic Rainforest Blend
  4. Newman’s Own Organics Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods
  5. Cameron’s Coffee Single Serve Pods Organic Breakfast Blend
  6. Military Grade Coffee K-Cups
  7. AmazonFresh Organic Fair Trade K-Cups Peru Medium Roast
  8. Green Mountain Coffee Fair Trade Organic Sumatran Reserve
  9. Peak Performance High Altitude Organic Coffee Pods
  10. Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC, Swiss Water Decaf Organic Peruvian Coffee Pods (decaf)

Editor’s Choice: Newman’s Own Organics – Keurig Organic Coffee To Love

Newman's Own Organics Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods

This “special blend” from Newman’s is organic coffee packed with all its deliciousness. Made with a mix of medium roast and dark roast coffee, the blend goes more towards the medium side. However, the dark roast makes its presence known and creates an excellent taste.

The coffee used is USDA certified organic and sourced from Central America and Indonesia. These two famous coffee-growing regions create quite a medley of tastes to enjoy with this K cup.

Get it on Amazon

Reviewed: Best Organic Coffee Pods For Single Serve Machines

1. Caza Trail Coffee Organic Extra Bold Single Serve Cups

Caza Trail Coffee Organic Extra Bold Single Serve Cups

Caza Trail Coffee Organic Extra Bold Single Serve Cups puts together beans from Latin America and Indonesia. This medium roast aims for moderate acidity with a full body and a smooth finish. It’s an enjoyable coffee with great aroma and taste.

The K cup takes the extra bold route to make the brew more enjoyable. Generally speaking, this implies there’s a bit more coffee in the K cup as compared to conventional. 

Though the coffee is sourced from different continents, they keep the necessary requirements close at home. All sourced coffee is USDA certified organic. They go the extra mile with other certifications, including fair trade and kosher.

K Cup Highlights

  • Medium roast coffee
  • Excellent blend of beans from Latin America and Indonesia
  • Great aroma and taste
  • Certifications: USDA Organic, Fair Trade, Kosher

Get it on Amazon

2. Death Wish Coffee Single Serve Capsules for Keurig K-Cup Brewers

Death Wish K Cups Packing

Death Wish Coffee Single Serve Capsules for Keurig K-Cup Brewers is one of the strongest K Cup coffees available. This brand is generally regarded as the purveyor of one of the strongest coffees ever. It’s packed with caffeine and will deliver a jolt of energy that’ll have you up and about in a sip.

lifeboost-coffee-fairtrade-organic-whole-bean-dark-roast-12oz

Try The Healthiest, Tastiest Organic Coffee Ever!


This deep, dark roast is a blend of robusta and arabica beans. While this is designed to be a strong and caffeine-rich coffee, it doesn’t ignore taste. It might flirt with the edge of bitterness, but never really goes there. In fact, you get to enjoy a smooth and bold drink with low acidity.

The subtle taste notes of cherry and chocolate make their presence felt clearly. Strong coffee with a great flavor is exactly what most of us want. Better still, the coffee is USDA certified organic so you can be assured of its quality. The only thing you need to watch here is your caffeine intake!

K Cup Highlights

  • Dark roast coffee 
  • Excellent taste and flavor
  • Blend of robusta and arabica coffee
  • Highly caffeinated
  • Certifications: USDA Organic, Fair Trade

Buy it on Amazon

3. SF Bay Coffee Organic Rainforest Blend

SF Bay Coffee Organic Rainforest Blend

SF Bay Coffee Organic Rainforest Blend is made from high quality beans sourced from Colombia, Mexico, Guatemala, and Indonesia. It’s a strong and smooth coffee with a great taste and flavor. 

Another great thing about this organic coffee is that it comes in compostable and biodegradable K cups. So not only does it take a better approach as an organic coffee, it also rids itself of the plastic waste that K cups are so prone to. These OneCup pods are made from plant-based materials and are commercially compostable.

Though the coffee is sourced from all over the world, SF Bay is very discerning about what beans go into your K cup. A medium roast coffee, this has undertones of sweet berry and dark chocolate to go along the bold taste. It is USDA certified organic, CCOF certified organic, and fair trade.

K Cup Highlights

  • Medium roast coffee
  • Excellent flavor and taste
  • The K Cup used is biodegradable and compostable
  • Taste undertones of berry and dark chocolates
  • Certifications: USDA organic, CCOF organic, Fair Trade, Kosher

See more on Amazon

4. Newman’s Own Organics Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods

Newman's Own Organics Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods

Newman’s Own Organics Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods are our top choice for this category. The blend brings together coffee beans from Central America and Indonesia to create an interesting taste. 

The Indonesian beans are a dark roast to deliver a rich and robust organic K cup. Beans sourced from Central America get a medium roast that highlights their flavor. Overall, the K cup seems to be more partial to the medium roast. This interesting blend and combination don’t fail to impress with their taste, body, and aroma.

They’ve been careful about the certifications as well. All beans used in this coffee are USDA certified organic. Other certifications include Orthodox Union Kosher and Fair Trade.

K Cup Highlights

  • A blend of medium and dark roast coffee
  • Bold taste and great flavor
  • Certifications: USDA organic, Fair Trade, Kosher

Buy it on Amazon

5. Cameron’s Coffee Single Serve Pods Organic Breakfast Blend

Cameron's Coffee Single Serve Pods, Organic Breakfast Blend

Cameron’s Coffee Single Serve Pods Organic Breakfast Blend highlights an excellent taste and aroma. This breakfast blend is a light roast with a bright acidity and a great body. They claim to use the best beans available in Central and South America. 

These beans are packed in a fully compostable and biodegradable K cup, which the company calls EcoPods. These pods are made from corn, beet, and wood, rather than using the conventional plastic. All ingredients are certified USDA organic 

K Cup Highlights

  • Excellent light roast for breakfast blend
  • Coffee beans sourced from Central and South America
  • Commercially compostable and biodegradable K Cup
  • Certifications: USDA Organic

See more on Amazon

6. Military Grade Coffee K-Cups

Military Grade Coffee K-Cups

Hey, it’s the strong and bold coffee made from some seriously high-strength K cups. Okay, maybe not that far, but Military Grade Coffee really does revel in a strong and bold brew. The coffee used here is a premium dark roast with taste notes of chocolate and caramel.

They advertise it as a very strong coffee. It also has a seriously high caffeine content to deliver a serious kick. The “double-duty caffeinated” K cups, as they call these, are made using non-GMO and USDA certified organic beans. 

According to the company, 10% of a purchase goes to The Gary Sinise Foundation with the aim of helping veterans.

K Cup Highlights

  • Strong, caffeinated K cup
  • Robust coffee in a dark roast
  • Portion of sales goes to charity intended for veterans
  • Certifications: USDA Organic

Get it on Amazon

7. AmazonFresh Organic Fair Trade K-Cups Peru Medium Roast

AmazonFresh Organic Fair Trade K-Cups

As the name suggests, this is Amazon’s own brand playing at the K Cup game. Most of Amazon’s in-house brands tend to take the value-for-money route. However, this one doesn’t seem shy to compete with the higher priced options. The coffee in these K cups is Peruvian coffee with a medium roast.

The brew is fragrant with a medium body and great flavor. Its roast allows the taste notes of brown sugar and chocolate to shine through, making it quite pleasant. 

At the time of writing, Amazon has a “satisfaction guarantee” program ongoing. The promise is that they’ll refund the purchase if you aren’t satisfied with the coffee. If you intend to purchase these, do check if the offer is still available. Sounds like a good deal for those willing to give this coffee a try.

The coffee used is certified USDA organic and has fair trade certification as well.

K Cup Highlights

  • Medium roast coffee
  • Coffee beans sourced from Peru
  • Taste notes of chocolate and brown sugar
  • Certifications: Fair Trade, USDA organic

See more on Amazon

8. Green Mountain Coffee Fair Trade Organic Sumatran Reserve

Green Mountain Coffee Fair Trade Organic Sumatran Reserve

Hailing from the famed coffee growing Sumatra region of Indonesia, this Keurig organic coffee has a great handle on quality and healthy-grown coffee. This dark roast caffeinated K cup brews a heavy-bodied and an exotic cuppa that will have you asking for more.

The taste notes of brown sugar and spice sit well with the aroma and the flavor of this lush coffee. It tastes pretty satisfying and has a good caffeine kick to go along.

K Cup Highlights

  • Wonderful dark roast
  • Taste notes of brown sugar and spice
  • Exotic, single-source coffee beans from Sumatra
  • Certifications: Fair Trade, USDA Organic, Orthodox Union Kosher

Buy it on Amazon

9. Peak Performance High Altitude Organic Coffee Pods

Peak Performance High Altitude Organic Coffee Pods

Made from high-quality single-source beans grown at a high altitude, Peak Performance covers several indicators of quality. The coffee tastes pretty strong but doesn’t get into being bitter. The coffee is sourced from the Guatemalan Highlands and is fairly good in taste.

Certifications for this one include Fair Trade and USDA certified organic. They also have a program where a portion of the profits is donated to charity to protect children at risk of malnutrition.

K Cup Highlights

  • Good quality coffee sourced from Guatemalan Highlands
  • Good taste and performance
  • Certifications: USDA organic, Fair Trade

See it on Amazon

10. Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC, Swiss Water Decaf Organic Peruvian Coffee Pods

Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC Swiss Water Decaf Organic Peruvian Coffee Pods

Fresh Roasted Coffee LLC has some pretty good gourmet coffee K cups available. They do especially well with half caff K cups and decaf. Decaf Organic Peruvian Coffee Pods are excellent organic decaf k cups. The single-source coffee is carefully handled and made from high-quality beans. 

They remain extra careful to ensure that the decaf process doesn’t rob any flavor from the beans, or add any undesirable flavor. It’s an exceptional medium roast with great taste and a touch of bold flavor. 

K Cup Highlights

  • Decaf
  • Medium roast
  • Gourmet coffee with excellent taste and flavor
  • Single source coffee from Cajamarca, Peru
  • Certifications: USDA Organic, Fair Trade, Orthodox Union Kosher

See more options, flavors, and discounts

Getting To Know Your Organic Coffee Better

What’s USDA Certified Organic?

You’ll notice that all of the K cups listed here are Certified USDA Organic. This is a program run by the United States Department of Agriculture for certifying organic produce. A certification means that the coffee is sourced from farms that are compliant to requirements of the program.

There are several requirements for this certification. A key requirement is that no synthetic chemical input should be made on the soil for at least three years prior to certification. Chemicals in this category include chemical fertilizers, pesticides, fungicides, sewage sludge, etc.

Included sites undergo periodic inspections and have to strictly adhere to rules. Comprehensive production and sales records must be available for audit. If a farm grows certified and non-certified products, there should be a strict separation between the products. There are a few more requirements, though these are the most important ones.

Why Choose Organic Coffee? 

Like any other industry, coffee production is under immense pressure to improve production and profits. Often, farmers may end up using (and overusing) a variety of chemicals to push for a better crop. There is always a chance that these chemicals make their way into your coffee. 

The overuse of chemicals like fertilizers, pesticides, etc. is also a growing ecological challenge that threatens ecosystems. 

Another problem with “regular” coffee is that unscrupulous vendors or sellers may end up fillers in coffee bags to artificially increase supply. Often these impurities are harmless like barley, wheat, rice, or other produce. Sometimes, there may be more serious problems like twigs, sticks, or dir. 

Even if they aren’t an immediate threat, they aren’t what you bought. And they certainly won’t do any favors to your cup of coffee. Packaging of organic coffee tends to be more careful in this regard. Since you get a product free of chemicals and unwanted additions, you’re more likely to get a healthy K cup with organic coffee.

To clarify, non-organic is not a doom and gloom scenario. Most of the times, your coffee is unlikely to have harmful substances. However, the process is clearly unsustainable and has major issues that need to be considered.

Is Organic Coffee Better Than Regular?

In some ways, yes, but not necessarily. The important thing is, to maintain their certification, everyone from coffee growers to sellers are more careful about the product. There are conscious efforts to be better and more sustainable. 

As the focus moves to sustainability, there’s a good chance you get better coffee. There’s an increased impetus on growing plants in a “natural” setting. Coffee plants prefer to grow in the shade of trees, but many farms would rather use the spot of the tree to grow more coffee plants! This leads to growing hybrid plants that can grow in the open, but sacrifice some flavor.

Considering the discouragement of synthetic chemicals and the chance of regular inspection, organic coffee gets a more controlled environment. That way, it might actually be better and a healthier option.

Zero-in On The Organic Coffee K Cup Of Your Choice

Choosing organic coffee can be the more responsible and reasonable path to take. There’s a good chance you’ll get a good coffee and healthier K cup. However, those of us who enjoy organic coffee, also know that there’s a lot of gimmicking going around. It’s important to steer clear of the gimmicks and put more stock in your own research and intelligence.

When buying the best organic coffee K-cups, don’t just take the word of the seller. It’s useful to look at the certification if you’re buying from a new brand. If possible, do a quick search to check if the certification actually exists.

My top recommendation for this category is the Newman’s Own Organics Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods. You can also give Caza Trail Coffee Organic Extra Bold Single Serve Cups a shot. And if you need more caffeine, take a look at Military Grade Coffee K-Cups.